Biological response to variation of acid-volatile sulfides and metals in field-exposed spiked sediments

Abstract Vertical and temporal variations of acid-volatile sulfides (AVS) and simultaneously extracted metals (SEM) in sediment can control biological impacts of metals. To assess the significance of these variations in field sediments, sediments spiked with cadmium, copper, lead, nickel, and zinc were deployed in Narragansett Bay for four months and recolonization by benthic organisms investigated. In surface sediments, concentrations of AVS decreased with time whenever AVS exceeded SEM but remained unchanged when AVS was less than SEM; in subsurface sediments, concentrations increased slightly. Concentrations of total SEM decreased with time only in surface sediments in which SEM exceeded AVS. Metals were not detected in interstitial waters of sediments where AVS exceeded SEM but were significant when SEM exceeded AVS and followed the order of solubilities of their sulfides. Concentrations in interstitial waters decreased with time, but exceeded U.S. Environmental Protection Agency chronic water quality criteria for 56 to 119 d. After 119 d, faunal assemblages in all treatments were similar to controls. Lack of biological response was related to vertical distributions of AVS and SEM. Biological exposure took place in near-surface sediments, where AVS exceeded SEM in even the highest treatments. Therefore, concentrations of metals in interstitial waters were low and consequently biological impacts were undetectable.