Reduced In-Person and Increased Telehealth Outpatient Visits During the COVID-19 Pandemic

Letters10 August 2020Reduced In-Person and Increased Telehealth Outpatient Visits During the COVID-19 PandemicFREEAaron Baum, PhD, Peter J. Kaboli, MD, MS, and Mark D. Schwartz, MDAaron Baum, PhDIcahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai and VA New York Harbor Healthcare System, New York, New York (A.B.)Search for more papers by this author, Peter J. Kaboli, MD, MSVeterans Rural Health Resource Center–Iowa City VA Office of Rural Health and Center for Access and Delivery Research and Evaluation, Iowa City VA Healthcare System, and University of Iowa Carver College of Medicine, Iowa City, Iowa (P.J.K.)Search for more papers by this author, and Mark D. Schwartz, MDVA New York Harbor Healthcare System and New York University School of Medicine, New York, New York (M.D.S.)Search for more papers by this authorAuthor, Article, and Disclosure Informationhttps://doi.org/10.7326/M20-3026 SectionsAboutVisual AbstractPDF ToolsAdd to favoritesDownload CitationsTrack CitationsPermissions ShareFacebookTwitterLinkedInRedditEmail Background: During the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, many health systems are postponing outpatient visits and shifting services to telehealth (1). However, the extent to which in-person visits have been reduced and replaced by telehealth visits remains unclear.Objective: To describe changes in the number of in-person, telephone, and video visits at U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) outpatient facilities during the initial 10 weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic, both overall and stratified by VA clinic.Methods and Findings: The VA is the largest health care provider in the United States and has implemented a robust COVID-19 plan in response to the pandemic. We analyzed data from the VA Corporate Data Warehouse, a national repository of electronic health records from visits to any VA facility that is updated nightly and has been previously assessed for reliability and accuracy (2).The study population included the cohort of adults who visited any VA health care facility between 2008 and 2018. Outcomes included the weekly number of VA outpatient visits, stratified by in-person, telephone, and video visits (based on VA clinic stop codes) and by clinic (based on the substation identifier where the encounter occurred). We limited visits to those classified by the VA as a completed patient encounter, which requires that the provider interacted with the patient and documented a diagnosis or procedure code and treatment plan and that the VA counted the visit toward the provider's workload.We described trends in weekly counts of each outcome during the first 20 weeks of 2016 to 2019 and of 2020. In addition, we reported changes in the count of each outcome during the initial 10-week pandemic period (weeks 11 to 20 of 2020, corresponding to 11 March to 19 May) versus the prior 10 weeks (weeks 1 to 10 of 2020, corresponding to 1 January to 10 March), both overall and by VA clinic.Analyses were done in Stata, version 15 (StataCorp). The Subcommittee for Human Studies at the VA New York Harbor Healthcare System (#01413) approved this study and waived patient informed consent.The number of in-person visits to a VA outpatient facility among patients in our cohort decreased from 18 898 656 in weeks 1 to 10 of 2020 to 8 408 268 in weeks 11 to 20, a reduction of 10 490 388 visits (−55.5%) (Figure 1). During the same period, the number of telephone visits increased from 2 539 685 to 6 070 362 (a 139.0% increase from weeks 1 to 10) and the number of video visits increased from 425 495 to 734 547 (a 72.6% increase from weeks 1 to 10). Overall, the total number of VA outpatient in-person and telehealth visits decreased from 21 863 836 in weeks 1 to 10 of 2020 to 15 213 177 in weeks 11 to 20, a reduction of 6 650 659 visits (−30.4%) (Figure 1). In contrast, the number of in-person, telephone, video, and overall outpatient visits did not change between weeks 1 to 10 and 11 to 20 of 2016 to 2019 (Figure 1).Figure 1. Number of VA outpatient visits per week in 2016 to 2019 and 2020.The solid line represents the total number of VA outpatient (any, in-person, video, and telephone) visits per week during 2020. The dashed line represents the weekly mean of the total number of VA outpatient (any, in-person, video, and telephone) visits per week in 2016 to 2019. Multiple outpatient records for the same person that shared the same date, clinic site, and primary clinic stop code were counted as 1 visit. The vertical line represents the week in 2020 when the COVID-19 pandemic began. COVID-19 = coronavirus disease 2019; VA = U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. Download figure Download PowerPoint Decreases in in-person visits and increases in telehealth visits were observed in 92.8% of VA clinics (Figure 2). Across clinics, the number of in-person visits decreased by a median of −60.1% (interquartile range, −48.7% to −73.3%), and the number of telehealth visits increased by a median of 116.4% (interquartile range, 55.2% to 210.3%).Figure 2. Percentage of change in in-person and telehealth outpatient visits during the COVID-19 pandemic, by VA clinic.Each circle represents a clinic, and the area of the circle is proportional to the clinic's size (defined as the number of unique patients who visited the clinic during 2019). The horizontal gray lines along the y-axis show the univariate distribution of the percentage of change in telephone and video visits across clinics, and the vertical gray lines along the x-axis show the univariate distribution of the percentage of change in in-person visits across clinics. COVID-19 = coronavirus disease 2019; VA = U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. Download figure Download PowerPoint Discussion: In this retrospective study of adults using VA care, there were 10 490 388 fewer in-person visits to VA outpatient facilities during the initial 10 weeks of the COVID-19 pandemic than in the preceding 10 weeks. The 56% decrease in in-person visits was partly offset by a more than 2-fold increase in the number of telephone and video visits, but overall there was still a 30% decrease in the number of outpatient visits. Limitations of this study include that veterans are predominantly male and older compared with the overall adult U.S. population and that we did not observe visits to non-VA providers. Further research is needed to understand how decreased access to in-person care and increased use of telehealth services during the pandemic may affect patient outcomes (3–5).References1. Hollander JE, Carr BG. Virtually perfect? Telemedicine for Covid-19. N Engl J Med. 2020;382:1679-1681. [PMID: 32160451] doi:10.1056/NEJMp2003539 CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar2. Fihn SD, Francis J, Clancy C, et al. Insights from advanced analytics at the Veterans Health Administration. Health Aff (Millwood). 2014;33:1203-11. [PMID: 25006147] doi:10.1377/hlthaff.2014.0054 CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar3. Starfield B, Shi L, Macinko J. Contribution of primary care to health systems and health. Milbank Q. 2005;83:457-502. [PMID: 16202000] CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar4. Basu S, Berkowitz SA, Phillips RL, et al. Association of primary care physician supply with population mortality in the United States, 2005-2015. JAMA Intern Med. 2019;179:506-514. [PMID: 30776056] doi:10.1001/jamainternmed.2018.7624 CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar5. Baum A, Barnett ML, Wisnivesky J, et al. Association between a temporary reduction in access to health care and long-term changes in hypertension control among veterans after a natural disaster. JAMA Netw Open. 2019;2:e1915111. [PMID: 31722027] doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2019.15111 CrossrefMedlineGoogle Scholar Comments 0 Comments Sign In to Submit A Comment Author, Article, and Disclosure InformationAuthors: Aaron Baum, PhD; Peter J. Kaboli, MD, MS; Mark D. Schwartz, MDAffiliations: Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai and VA New York Harbor Healthcare System, New York, New York (A.B.)Veterans Rural Health Resource Center–Iowa City VA Office of Rural Health and Center for Access and Delivery Research and Evaluation, Iowa City VA Healthcare System, and University of Iowa Carver College of Medicine, Iowa City, Iowa (P.J.K.)VA New York Harbor Healthcare System and New York University School of Medicine, New York, New York (M.D.S.)See also: Editorial comment (page 116).Disclaimer: The funders had no role in the design or conduct of the study; collection, management, analysis, or interpretation of the data; preparation, review, or approval of the manuscript; or the decision to submit the manuscript for publication. The views expressed in this article are those of the authors and do not necessarily represent the views of the VA or the U.S. government.Financial Support: This material is the result of work supported with resources of the VA New York Harbor Healthcare System. Dr. Kaboli is supported by the VA, Veterans Health Administration, VA Office of Rural Health and Office of Research and Development, and the Health Services Research and Development service through the Center for Access and Delivery Research and Evaluation (CIN 13-412).Disclosures: Disclosures can be viewed at www.acponline.org/authors/icmje/ConflictOfInterestForms.do?msNum=M20-3026.Reproducible Research Statement: Study protocol: Not available. Statistical code: Available from Dr. Baum (e-mail, aaron.baum@mssm.edu). Data set: Access to the underlying data is restricted to VA employees with an institutional review board–approved and VA-approved research project.Corresponding Author: Aaron Baum, PhD, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai and VA New York Harbor Healthcare System, 1216 Fifth Avenue, Suite 559, New York, NY 10029; e-mail, aaron.baum@mssm.edu.This article was published at Annals.org on 10 August 2020. PreviousarticleNextarticle Advertisement FiguresReferencesRelatedDetailsSee AlsoVirtual Care and the Pandemic: Are We Reaching All Patients? Carolyn M. Clancy and Susan Kirsh Metrics Cited byDisparities in routine healthcare utilization disruptions during COVID-19 pandemic among veterans with type 2 diabetesNational trends in the prevalence of chronic kidney disease among Korean adults, 2007–2020The COVID-19 pandemic did not negatively impact frequency or continuity of outpatient care in Alberta, CanadaDetermining the Trend of Public Interest in Pediatric Solid Tumors: A Pre- and Post-COVID Pandemic AnalysisImpacts of COVID-19 on Drug Treatment Court Operations: Lessons Learned Through Normalization Process TheoryThe professional agenda and its effect on the implementation of telemedicine among primary care physicians: A qualitative studyVisit and Between-Visit Interaction Frequency Before and After COVID-19 Telehealth ImplementationVideoconferencing of Movement-Based and Psychologically Informed Interventions for Chronic Pain: A Systematic Review and Horizon ScanImpact of COVID-19 pandemic on nonpharmacological pain management trials in military and veteran healthcare settings: an evaluation informed by implementation scienceBrief Report: Telehealth Music-Enhanced Reciprocal Imitation Training in Autism: A Single-Subject Feasibility Study of a Virtual Parent Coaching InterventionChanges in lifestyle-related behaviour during the COVID-19 pandemic in Japan: a questionnaire survey for examinees who underwent an annual health check-upQuantifying the Digital Divide: Associations of Broadband Internet with Tele-mental Health Access Before and During the COVID-19 PandemicPatient and provider perspectives of personal health record use: a multisite qualitative study in HIV care settingsChanges in Burnout and Moral Distress Among Veterans Health Administration (VA) Physicians Before and During the COVID-19 PandemicExcess Mortality at Veterans Health Administration Facilities During the COVID-19 PandemicEvaluating the effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of free influenza vaccination policy for older adults in Yinzhou, China: Study protocol of a real-world analysesArtificial intelligence-assisted smartphone-based sensing for bioanalytical applications: A reviewThe impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on blood pressure control after a stroke or transient ischemic attack among patients at VA medical centersEffectiveness of a Smoking Cessation Program during the COVID-19 PandemicPatient Characteristics Associated with Telehealth Scheduling and Completion in Primary Care at a Large, Urban Public Healthcare SystemHealth Care Implications of the COVID-19 Pandemic for the Cardiovascular Practitioner“Giving the patients less work”: A thematic analysis of telehealth use and recommendations to improve usability for autistic adultsThe latent tuberculosis infection cascade of care during the COVID-19 pandemic response in a Mid-Sized US cityReceipt of Medications for Chronic Disease During the First 2 Years of the COVID-19 Pandemic Among Enrollees in Fee-for-Service MedicarePayment and Coverage Parity for Virtual Care and In-Person Care: How Do We Get There?Coping with COVID: Performance of China’s hierarchical medical system during the COVID-19 pandemicImpact of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Health Care Utilization in the Vaccine Safety Datalink: Retrospective Cohort Study (Preprint)Navigating COVID-19 and related challenges to completing clinical trials: Lessons from the PATRIOT and STEP-UP randomized prevention trialsCommunity-integrated self-collected HPV-based cervix screening in a low-resource rural setting: a pragmatic, cluster-randomized trialDisparities in Telemedicine Use Among Louisiana Medicaid Beneficiaries During the COVID-19 PandemicImpact of COVID-19 on Trends in Outpatient Clinic UtilizationPrivate equity in ophthalmology and optometry: a time series analysis from 2012 to 2021Evaluation of Outpatient Access to the Greek Health System Considering the Constraints of the COVID-19 PandemicEvaluation of a Telehealth Training Package to Remotely Teach Caregivers to Conduct Discrete-Trial InstructionUsing Telehealth to Provide Interventions for Children with ASD: a Systematic ReviewA Pilot Study of Brief, Stepped Behavioral Activation for Primary Care Patients with Depressive SymptomsExploration of Cardiology Patient Hospital Presentations, Health Care Utilisation and Cardiovascular Risk Factors During the COVID-19 PandemicInforming Use of Telehealth for Managing Chronic Conditions: Mixed‐Methods Evaluation of Telehealth Use to Manage Heart Failure During COVID‐19Frequency and Type of Outpatient Visits for Patients With Cardiovascular Ambulatory‐Care Sensitive Conditions During the COVID‐19 Pandemic and Subsequent Outcomes: A Retrospective Cohort StudyDIGItal Health Literacy after COVID-19 Outbreak among Frail and Non-Frail Cardiology Patients: The DIGI-COVID StudyTelehealth use in Australian primary healthcare during COVID-19: a cross-sectional descriptive surveyCharacteristics and Health Care Use of Patients Attending Virtual Walk-in Clinics in Ontario, Canada: Cross-sectional AnalysisOccupational Factors Associated with Telemedicine Use in the Japanese Working-Age Population: A Web-Based Study Conducted during the COVID-19 PandemicEffect of the Announcement of Human-to-Human Transmission on Telemedicine Services in China During COVID-19Noninterventional studies in the COVID-19 era: methodological considerations for study design and analysisEthical Dilemmas Facing Substance Use Counselors During the COVID-19 PandemicReproducibility and Acceptability of Short Physical Function Tests Scores Obtained via Virtual versus Face-to-Face AssessmentsVideo-Based Educational Interventions for Patients With Chronic Illnesses: Systematic ReviewChanges in mobility amid the COVID-19 pandemic in Sapporo City, Japan: An investigation through the relationship between spatiotemporal population density and urban facilitiesInfluence of synchronous primary care telemedicine versus in-person visits on diabetes, hypertension, and hyperlipidemia outcomes: a systematic reviewVeterans’ ambulatory care experience during COVID-19: veterans’ access to and satisfaction with primary care early in the pandemicA multicentre validation study of a smartphone application to screen hand arthritisOutpatient visit trends for internal medicine ambulatory care sensitive conditions after the COVID-19 pandemic: a time-series analysisExploring the Digital Divide among the Bhutanese Refugee Community during COVID-19: Engaged Research in ActionTelemedicine, safe medication stewardship, and COVID-19: Digital transformation during a global pandemicAn Analysis of Google Trends During COVID-19: Determining Public Urological Cancer ConcernsThe use of virtual visits for obesity pharmacotherapy in patients with overweight or obesity compared with in‐person encountersHospital-based ambulatory clinic adoption of video and telephone visits before and during the COVID-19 pandemic: a convergent mixed-methods studyInfluence of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Overall Physician Visits and Telemedicine Use Among Patients With Type 1 or Type 2 Diabetes in JapanAssociation of Adequacy of Broadband Internet Service With Access to Primary Care in the Veterans Health Administration Before and During the COVID-19 PandemicCollateral effect of the COVID-19 pandemic on cardiology service provision and cardiovascular mortality in a population-based study: COVID-COR-LTA Thin Line Between Helpful and Harmful Internet Usage: Embodied Research on Internet Experiences Among Adolescent and Young Adult Cancer PatientsGeneral practice perspective on the use of telehealth during the COVID-19 pandemic in Australia using an Action Research approach: a qualitative studyImpacto de la pandemia del COVID-19 en la carga de trabajo de la radiología en ColombiaEffect of a Comprehensive Telehealth Intervention vs Telemonitoring and Care Coordination in Patients With Persistently Poor Type 2 Diabetes ControlChanges in US Veterans’ Access to Specialty Care During the COVID-19 PandemicThe influence of the pandemic on fear of contagion, blood pressure management and adherence to medication in hypertensive older adults in TurkeyAccess to Telepharmacy Services May Reduce Hospital Admissions in Outpatient Populations During the COVID-19 PandemicChanges in industry marketing payments to physicians during the covid-19 pandemic: quasi experimental, difference-in-difference studyBehavioral activation for live-in migrant home care workers and care recipients in Israel: a pilot studyImplementation of Telehealth for Psychiatric Care in VA Emergency Departments and Urgent Care ClinicsUsing Administrative Data to Examine Telemedicine Usage Among Medicaid Beneficiaries During the Coronavirus Disease 2019 PandemicHow essential are in‐person clinic visits during maintenance treatment of children with acute lymphoblastic leukemia?Quality of Care and Outcomes for Patients with Acute Ischemic Stroke and Transient Ischemic Attack During the COVID-19 PandemicImpact of COVID-19 on People Experiencing Homelessness: A Call for Critical AccountabilityProcess mining-driven analysis of COVID-19’s impact on vaccination patternsCOVID ‐19 behavioral questionnaire ( CoBQ ): Comparing the pandemic's impact on health behavior in three US statesThe Impact of the Covid-19-Related Transition to Telehealth on Visit Adherence in Mental Health Care: An Interrupted Time Series StudyA Primary Care Telehealth Pilot Program to Improve Access: Associations with Patients' Health Care Utilization and CostsChanges in incidence rates of outcomes of interest in vaccine safety studies during the COVID-19 pandemicThe impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on medical conditions and medication adherence in people with chronic diseasesECG Utilization Patterns of Patients With Arrhythmias During COVID-19 Epidemic and Post-SARS-CoV-2 Eras in Shanghai, ChinaCrossing the digital divide: a veteran affairs program to distribute video-enabled devices to patients in a supportive housing programOutpatient Wound Clinics During COVID-19 Maintained Quality but Served Fewer PatientsImpact of telehealth on health care resource utilization during the COVID-19 pandemicTrends and Disparities in the Use of Telehealth Among Injured Workers During the COVID-19 PandemicImpact of transition from face‐to‐face to telehealth on behavioral obesity treatment during the COVID‐19 pandemicTelehealth Use Among Older Adults During COVID-19: Associations With Sociodemographic and Health Characteristics, Technology Device Ownership, and Technology LearningManagement of colorectal cancer during the COVID‐19 pandemic: Recommendations from a statewide multidisciplinary cancer collaborativeMedication prescribing in face-to-face versus telehealth consultations during the COVID-19 pandemic in Australian general practice: a retrospective observational studyTelehealth-based diagnostic testing in general practice during the COVID-19 pandemic: an observational studyVirtual Specialist Care during the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Multi-Method Study of Patient Experience (Preprint)Leveraging Telehealth to Improve Diabetes CareDevelopment of telemedicine tools with an emphasis on visual observationTreatment Persistence of Renin-Angiotensin-Aldosterone-System Inhibitors Over Time in Heart Failure with Reduced Ejection FractionDisruption of Medical Care among Individuals in the Southeastern United States during the COVID-19 PandemicUse of Wearables and Implantable Devices to Monitor Pulmonary Health in the Outpatient SettingUse of Extended Reality in Medicine During the Covid-19 PandemicA multicenter randomized controlled trial comparing gamification with remote monitoring against standard rehabilitation for patients after arthroscopic shoulder Visits and Among Patients With During the COVID-19 Health Care During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Managing the Health for the of Chronic Conditions: Systematic of Health and in Adults with of the COVID-19 pandemic on in for A health Care Utilization Among Veterans Health Administration Enrollees Before and After and Disparities in with physician during the COVID-19 Trends in Emergency Department the Coronavirus Disease 2019 Pandemic in Among Coronavirus Disease A Korean Cohort Care to Improve Diabetes Outcomes in Refugee and Patients to during the COVID-19 PandemicChanges in Treatment of Patients with during the Coronavirus Disease 2019 of in US Veterans Health Administration Care Delivery During the COVID-19 PandemicThe impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and at home on care using service during the COVID‐19 pandemic: a cohort study in the US Department of Veterans in the Use of Telehealth and Care in the Department of Veterans Affairs Before and After the COVID-19 to Telehealth An Study of Telehealth during the COVID-19 Health and Use and during the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Center by Associated With Fewer Subsequent Face-to-Face Healthcare visits and medication for chronic during the COVID-19 pandemic in Japan: retrospective cohort and to of the COVID-19 Pandemic for Cardiovascular Disease and physicians by in of Care at a How Telemedicine to the Patient as a Care and the Pandemic: Are We Reaching All M. and Susan MD, of the COVID-19 Pandemic on Health Care Utilization in a Health Care Retrospective Cohort of Research and Health Care Visits During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Cross-sectional and Disparities in the Use of Telemedicine During the COVID-19 Pandemic in Japan: Cross-sectional Administrative Data to of Virtual Care During COVID-19: Retrospective Cohort Study of in Outpatient and Telehealth Visits During the COVID-19 Pandemic in a Health Care Retrospective Cohort of the Coronavirus Disease 2019 (COVID-19) Pandemic on Medical Use of in care use before and during the COVID-19 pandemic: a cross-sectional of Patients with Cardiovascular During COVID-19 Epidemic and in Shanghai, of COVID-19 Pandemic on Cancer Care Disease 2019 (COVID-19) in a Patient with and from and Review January 1 Adults COVID-19 Disclosure Health care Health care facilities Outpatient clinics Telemedicine care 10 August 2020 January