Comment on egusphere-2025-4625

<strong class="journal-contentHeaderColor">Abstract.</strong> Deforestation for cropland expansion in tropical sloping landscapes causes severe soil erosion and thus the loss of fertile, organic rich topsoil. The effects of land degradation on tropical soils developed from different parent materials, which may influence soil fertility and soil organic carbon (SOC) content, are still largely unknown. Here, we compared SOC and other soil fertility indicators in undisturbed tropical forest topsoils with cleared hillslope topsoils (cropland, abandoned, cropland, and reforestation with <em>Eucalyptus</em> monocultures) along the East African rift system using soil chronosequences after deforestation on both mafic and felsic parent material. In the mafic region, we found a consistent decrease of SOC, nitrogen, and phosphorus content with time after deforestation (relative changes of contents up to &minus;69 % SOC, &minus;72 % nitrogen, and &minus;92 % phosphorus). SOC was strongly stabilized by reactive metal phases with little to no benefits to general soil fertility. Consequently, cropland was frequently abandoned by farmers due to the combination of low pH, high Al³⁺ mobility, and low available nutrient status at a relatively high average SOC content of 14&ndash;29 g kg^&minus;1 in topsoils. In the felsic region, mid-Holocene carbonate volcanism mitigated soil degradation to some extent. In both geochemical regions, SOC content did not or only weakly positively correlate with clay content and cation exchange capacity. These results emphasize that soil organic matter, as well as clay content, appear to be unreliable indicators for soil fertility in degraded tropical cropland soils. Additionally, no significant improvement of soil fertility or SOC stocks was observed after replanting degraded fields with <em>Eucalyptus </em>monocultures. The estimated lifespan of croplands on hillslopes in our study area, approximately 100&ndash;170 years, underscores the severity of soil degradation for food production and forest protection in the upcoming decades, especially considering that many soils are already approaching this age.