Including parameter uncertainty in loss distributions using calibrating priors

Abstract We revisit the question of how to include parameter uncertainty in univariate parametric models of losses and loss ratios. We first review the statistical theory for including parameter uncertainty based on right Haar priors (RHPs), which applies to many commonly used models. In this theory, the prior is chosen in such a way as to ensure matching between predicted probabilities and the relative frequencies of future outcomes in repeated tests. This property is known as reliability, or calibration. We then test priors for including parameter uncertainty in a number of models not covered by RHP theory. For these models, we find priors that generate predictions that are more reliable than predictions based on maximum likelihood, although they are not perfectly reliable. We discuss numerical schemes that can be used to generate Bayesian predictions, including a novel use of asymptotic expansions, and we include an example in which we show the impact of including parameter uncertainty in the modeling of extreme hurricane losses. The tail loss estimates show material increases due to the inclusion of parameter uncertainty. Finally, we describe a new software library that makes it straightforward to apply the methods we describe.