Designing Resilient Drinking Water Systems for Treating Eutrophic Sources: A Holistic Evaluation of Biological Stability and Treatment Sequence

Designing robust drinking water treatment schemes for eutrophic sources requires shifting from considering each treatment step separately to considering the full treatment process as a connected system. This study evaluated how treatment configuration and arrangement influence microbial community dynamics, organic carbon removal, and biological stability in a full-scale drinking water treatment plant. A Dutch treatment plant was monitored, operating two parallel lines: one conventional (coagulation, sedimentation, and rapid sand filtration) and one advanced (ion exchange, ceramic microfiltration, and advanced oxidation), both converging into granular activated carbon (GAC) filtration. Microbial and chemical water quality was assessed across treatment stages and seasons. This plant experiences periods of discoloration, taste, and odor issues, and an exceedance of Aeromonas counts in the distribution network. Advanced oxidation achieved a high bacterial cell inactivation (~90%); however, it significantly increased assimilable organic carbon (AOC) (300–900% increase), challenging biological stability. GAC filtration partially reduced AOC levels (from 70 μg Ac-C/L to 12 μg Ac-C/L) but also supported dense (105 cells/mL) and diverse microbial communities (Shannon diversity index 5.83). Moreover, Gammaproteobacteria, which harbor opportunistic pathogens such as Aeromonas, persisted during the treatment. Archaea were highly sensitive to oxidative and physical stress, leading to reduced diversity downstream. Beta diversity analysis revealed that treatment configuration, rather than seasonality, governed the community composition. The findings highlight that treatment arrangement, oxidation, GAC operation, and organic and microbial loads critically influence biological stability. This study proposes integrated strategies to achieve resilient and biologically stable drinking water production when utilizing complex water sources such as eutrophic lakes.