Report of a one-day convening on regulatory science, practices, and innovative approaches to facilitate approval of novel combination vaccines

Combination vaccine formulations contain distinct components targeting multiple strains of a single pathogen or multiple pathogens. By minimizing the number of separate vaccine administrations required, combination vaccines have been critical in allowing the broad expansion of the number and range of diseases that can now be prevented by immunization. Recent advances in vaccine development and our understanding of the immune system now make it possible to envision how new combination vaccines could play a major role in helping immunization programs address a much wider range of emerging or still problematic pathogens. However, few combinations are currently in the pipeline, in part due to their inherently increased complexity and cost of development compared to standalone formulations. This complexity, in turn, is partly driven by the regulatory requirements surrounding the clinical study program for the combination vaccine, especially the primary clinical endpoints and the required degree of precision around those endpoints, as these ultimately determine the sample size, cost, and duration of the study. As part of a larger effort to facilitate combination vaccine development, vaccine experts at the World Health Organization and PATH coordinated a one-day meeting in March 2025 gathering current and former national regulatory agency staff from a dozen countries, together with vaccine developers, representatives from funding and procurement agencies, and public health and policy officials. The convened participants held spirited discussions on how multiple immune markers and controlled human infection models (CHIM) might contribute to the demonstration of vaccine efficacy. In addition, participants considered the possibility of relying on clinical endpoints when the vaccine components are directed against pathogens causing the same disease syndrome but etiological determination of each component's contribution is not feasible. Regulators welcomed scientifically sound, creative proposals for demonstration of efficacy, and agreed that the benefit-risk of the combination vaccine as a whole should be the primary focus.