Decoding the Middle Tonian Tectonic Evolution of the Jiangnan Orogen, South China: Integrated Constraints from Volcano-Sedimentary and Magmatic Records of the Fanjingshan Region

The Middle Tonian tectonic setting of the Jiangnan Orogen, South China, remains intensely debated, and is centered on two competing models: subduction–collision versus mantle plume. This study addresses this critical knowledge gap through an integrated, multi-proxy investigation of the Middle Tonian Fanjingshan Group. This region preserves a continuous volcano-sedimentary and magmatic record, offering key insights into the orogen’s full lifecycle. To test these hypotheses, we employed a synthesis of geological survey, sediment provenance analysis, detrital zircon U-Pb geochronology of clastic rocks to determine sediment provenance and basin evolution, and petrogenetic study of coeval magmatic suites (pillow lava, mafic–ultramafic sills, and granitoids) to evaluate their magmatic processes and tectonic setting. Analysis of 1736 detrital zircon U-Pb ages from Middle Tonian strata reveals a four-stage provenance evolution: (1) SW Yangtze sources in a passive margin basin before 870 Ma; (2) bidirectional sources in an 870–835 Ma arc-derived basin; (3) syn-collisional detritus during 835–820 Ma amalgamation; and (4) post-collisional and northern Yangtze inputs in an 800 Ma rifting basin. Geochemical data from ~845–840 Ma basalts and coeval sills reveal calc-alkaline affinities and marked subduction-fluid signatures. Their calculated mantle potential temperature (1404 °C) is significantly lower than that expected for plume-derived melts (1570 °C), which is consistent with melting in a subduction-modified mantle wedge, supporting a continental rear-arc basin setting. The ~845–832 Ma mafic–ultramafic sills exhibit symmetrical geochemical zoning and two-stage emplacement, recording sustained magma recharge in the rear-arc basin. Furthermore, the ~830 Ma Fanjingshan granite is identified as a crust-derived, syn-collisional S-type granite. Synthesizing these findings, we demonstrate that the sedimentary and magmatic records collectively point to plate margin setting. A four-stage tectonic model is suggested: (1) pre-870 Ma passive margin without significant magmatic activity; (2) 870–835 Ma continental arc development at an active continental margin; (3) 835–820 Ma Yangtze–Cathaysia collision; and (4) post-820 Ma post-orogenic rifting. This work provides a robust regional case study, demonstrating that integrating records of deep magmatic processes with coeval shifts in sedimentary provenance and basin architecture is essential to reconstruct the complete evolution of ancient orogens.