A mosaic of climate vulnerability: local warming rates meet intraspecific divergence in heat tolerance

Abstract Climate warming is increasing mismatches between thermal phenotypes and habitat temperatures, driving range shifts and population extirpations. While within-species variation in heat tolerance and local warming rates can predict responses to climate warming, how these factors shape differences in vulnerability among taxa and ecosystems is uncertain. Here we combine climate and thermal trait data from 69 species across four ecosystem types to examine the effects of incorporating intraspecific variation in heat tolerance and local warming rates on projected vulnerability to climate warming. Because vulnerability to warming depends on existing phenotypic variation in thermal performance and relative rates of habitat warming, we develop a new metric that integrates localized rates of warming with spatial variation in thermal tolerances, termed the ‘minimum trait velocity’. Incorporating intraspecific variation in heat tolerance lowered estimates of warming tolerance (a measure of vulnerability) across most ecosystem types, with the strongest negative impact on marine taxa. Although intraspecific variation in heat tolerance could facilitate adaptation to climate change, our results suggest such variation is generally less than the projected near future warming. This suggests that opportunities for evolutionary rescue via gene flow between locally adapted populations are limited, adding to mounting concern as the climate warms.