Comment on egusphere-2026-980

<strong class="journal-contentHeaderColor">Abstract.</strong> The assessment of soil health relies on sensitive indicators to detect management-induced changes, yet the analytical reliability of these indicators following long-term storage is rarely assessed. We investigated how multi-year storage of air-dried samples influenced the concentrations of several common soil health indicators, including water-extractable organic carbon and nitrogen (WEOC, WEN), mineralizable carbon (Cmin), and permanganate-oxidizable carbon (POX-C), using archived samples from a cover crop experiment. Concentrations of WEOC nearly doubled after three years of storage, while WEN decreased by 19%. A small but significant 6% increase in Cmin concentration was also observed. In contrast, POX-C concentrations remained stable, indicating robustness to storage effects. These storage effects were consistent among three treatments with different cover crop species. In addition, WEOC concentrations consistently declined over time in this experiment and four long-term agricultural sites in the USA, but bulk soil organic carbon (SOC) or soil organic matter (SOM) did not. These results suggest that multi-year storage of air-dried samples inflates the WEOC pool. Therefore, we caution the use of WEOC as a soil health indicator in archived samples, as the observed variations might reflect storage artifacts rather than genuine management impacts.